Puzzles, Problems and Predicaments

Puzzles, Problems and Predicaments

Not all issues that require creative solutions are the same type, so the same approach or way of thinking will not necessarily work. The classes of issue are Puzzles, Problems and Predicaments. These classes are distinctly different.

A Puzzle is essentially mechanical in nature. It is solved using logic, existing knowledge and skill with new information uncovered during the solving process. There is often a small range of possible solutions and sometimes only one. The objectives are clear and often shared. The values and feelings of the people involved centre on succeeding, contributing, cooperating, and competing. Those involved usually accept the desirability of a solution.

Puzzles could be: – repairing a washing machine, solving a crossword puzzle, building a model boat, buying a pair of shoes, playing tennis, building a car, or getting a person to the moon. Although these puzzles are mechanical, there is scope for much skill, flair, and knowledge.

A Problem may have many mechanical components, but these do not determine its difficulty. Problems are more than mechanical. Conflicting feelings, beliefs, prejudices, interests and values are involved. History is important. The complicating factor in problems is the presence of strong emotions. The objectives are often not clear and may not be shared. Most political problems fall in this category. Solving a problem requires objectivity, self-knowledge, and the ability to accept and release others’ feelings. Above all, it requires the ability to listen, suspend judgment, and understand.

Problems include: – getting organisations to change their habits, building prosperous and healthy inner cities, encouraging healthy eating, deciding where to go on holiday together as a family, deciding how to educate children, and getting staff to work together.

A Predicament is a Problem at a deeper level. It may involve mechanical and emotional elements, but its essence is spiritual. A solution appears to involve damage or destruction of the self, group or community. Solving a predicament requires a willingness to accept the contradiction that both the present situation and the new situation are intolerable. Out of this acceptance, new resources can well up and create transformation.

Predicaments require a personal change to resolve or transform them. For example, a family could face the predicament of loving a teenage child yet finding them very difficult to live with. Observing that child’s courage when facing a severe disappointment might change the family attitude. They could then convey their appreciation so positively that the child’s attention-seeking behaviour is no longer functional. The trigger for such a change in perception is often the caring interest and attention of someone else.

Personal predicaments include coping with serious illness, looking after aged parents and maintaining a family, staying married when divorce is ‘easy’ or concentrating on a child or a career. A work predicament could be deciding to work with an affluent or an impoverished client. Your Company is profitable but behaves unethically. Should you stay and keep quiet, go and keep quiet, blow the whistle or change it from the inside?

Implications for Organisations and their Managers

It would be easier if issues in organisations were mostly Puzzles, mechanical in nature. Unfortunately, they are not. In practice, all but the simplest issues contain problems, predicaments and puzzles. It is very important to recognise that these dimensions exist and that mechanical ‘techniques’ either will not work or will produce unanticipated side effects in more complex situations. Two examples follow.

Family issues

A new factory is at the other end of the country. The best-qualified person is X. The Company sends for X and asks X to do the job. The Company has solved the Puzzle. Unfortunately, there is a Problem. X has a close relative who is ill and lives locally, and X is unwilling to leave while X can be of some help.

You, the Company representative, have a Predicament. You know X and the situation regarding the relative, and believe it is right for X not to move. Your boss is leaning on you for a quick solution. They believe X is the right person. You have to insist that X moves to the factory. X leaves the Company for your local rival.

Training is not the answer to everything.

The quality of customer service in an area is consistently poor. You decide to set up customer care training to address the problem. You have solved the Puzzle. Unfortunately, there are Problems. The managers in this area have consistently been poor ‘people managers’ over the year. The organisation has neglected the facilities. They are dirty, and the employees are underpaid. As a result, everyone feels angry, frustrated, and uncared for. You followed up on the training, and there has been no improvement in customer service. Several employees have left, having finally realised how fed up they are.

You now have a Predicament: what to do next. Do you blame the circumstances and the group for a poor outcome, or blame yourself for an error of judgment in expecting the quick fix to work? You struggle with this and finally decide to use this experience to understand the issue.

You work with the group to develop a systematic strategy for customer care. This strategy considers all the influences on this process. It works.

Commentary

Puzzles, Problems, and Predicaments usually occur together. Each type requires different handling.

Puzzles, being logical, require accurate, objective information. Most of the parameters of a mechanical puzzle are measurable. People work together in an atmosphere that encourages the sharing of information and technical ideas. Techniques that can help include brainstorming, drawing pictures, thinking and listening, and building models. The atmosphere is practically intellectual. Ideas are useful if they contribute to achieving a practical goal.

Problems carry an emotional element as well. People need to share objective information, but it is also important to include how they are feeling. People need to feel safe when sharing emotional information. They feel very vulnerable while doing so. It helps if they talk in pairs or very small groups. The participants will value listening and paying attention to each other.

Groups are better able to listen to one another when members feel good about themselves. Mutual listening is necessary when two or more subgroups have a history of disliking, hating or mistrust. Permitting people to express their feelings of anger, fear, sadness, and embarrassment also helps progress. Give everyone equal time to speak and listen without judging.

There are a few additional ‘techniques’ other than those outlined above. An attitude of trying to understand rather than judge is essential. Counselling skills for handling strong emotions are very useful. Some structured problem-solving workshops have worked well when adapted to a particular situation and organisation.

Predicaments are personal and deep, affecting a person’s sense of identity and self-worth. People need time and acceptance to work things through to a resolution. They need to call on their inner resources, resources they may not even know exist. Some see these resources as God or faith, and as gifts from beyond the person. When a resolution does happen, it leads to a changed person who is more whole, integrated and generous-hearted (less self-centred).

The attitude of others toward the person in a predicament is one of loving acceptance. There is nothing we can do except ‘be there’ and show we care. If I know you love me, this will release the resources I need.

People find it easier to help with others’ predicaments if they have resolved a few of their own.

Conclusion

In most real situations, there are Puzzle (mechanical), Problem (emotional) and Predicament (spiritual) elements. Techniques are more useful in the mechanical area. Being there, listening, sharing, and accepting work well at all levels. Any approach requires flexibility based on understanding.